Skip to main content

Essay

Star Trek | Wrath of Khan at 40: Kirk's Mid-Life Crisis Enters Middle Age

Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan shows an aging Kirk struggling with relevance and purpose in a changing world – an experience mirrored by the series itself.

While recent re-evaluations of Star Trek: The Motion Picture have praised its slower pace and the opulent way it portrays space exploration, there’s no doubt its original release disappointed both fans and the suits at Paramount. A lack of camaraderie and humor from The Original Series turned off the former. At the same time, the studio execs bristled at its mediocre performance at the box office, at least in comparison to blockbuster peers such as Close Encounters of the Third Kind (1977). The financial complaint was unfair: The Motion Picture made decent money, but something had to change if the series was to continue.

In the history of movie sequels, there can be few jumps in tone, scope, and theme as significant as the one between Star Trek: The Motion Picture and its follow-up, The Wrath of Khan (1982). Against creator Gene Roddenberry’s preference, gone was the exploratory vocation of Starfleet, replaced with a militaristic organization busy policing the cosmos. There are tropes such as space battles waged between powerful spaceships and all their associations: explosions, desperate maneuvers, and theatrical exclamations of ‘FIRE!’. The shift worked, appealing to audiences and setting the mood for future Star Trek movies.

Enterprise takes fire in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982). | Paramount, 1982.

Even Roddenberry himself appeared at peace, despite his reduction to an executive consultant role. “My Star Trek is in the past, and I feel terribly good about that,” he wrote in a letter to his friend Rupert Evans from the book Star Trek Creator (1994). “[…] Putting it there has also lifted a heavy weight from my shoulders.” On the surface, it seemed that Gene Roddenberry had moved on, and Star Trek had moved into an era of exciting blockbuster action.

Star Trek | How the Star Trek Adventures RPG Spans the Generations

Star Trek Adventures product manager Jim Johnson takes us inside the quiet revolution that made 2022 the year his table-top RPG truly arrived.

Middle-Aged Angst in The Wrath of Khan

Yet underpinning all of Wrath of Khan’s phaser fire, interpersonal drama, and unwanted blasts from the past is a constant theme of age, specifically middle age, experience, and how we deal with these concepts, despite what Dr. McCoy (DeForest Kelly) states early on in the film. “This is not about age – and you know it,” says the good doctor as he and Kirk ‘celebrate’ the latter’s birthday. “It’s about you flying a goddamn computer console when you wanna be out there hopping galaxies.” For once, I can’t help but disagree with Bones – it is about age and the common work dilemma of moving farther away from the role you love as you get older. Except this isn’t a staff writer moving through editorial and publishing roles, creating less and less copy as they rise; this is a starship captain, an explorer of the unknown, relegated to spending his time watching others depart Earth to do just that. This is emphasized in the film’s first scene when a lachrymose Kirk judges the trainee crew of Enterprise during a test exercise. 

Admiral Kirk (William Shatner) supervises Saavik (Kirstie Alley) in the Kobayashi Maru in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982). The film was the first to introduce naval-inspired uniforms that lasted until The Next Generation era. | Paramount, 1982.

Kirk is finally getting old. According to Wrath of Khan’s script, the hero of Starfleet is on the cusp of his 50s. Seeing the young crew, most of them at least half his age inevitably evokes memories of his youth. Bones, almost mockingly, gives him a pair of antique reading glasses as a birthday present. Kirk is unimpressed, and the first ten minutes is a study of a man going nowhere, both physically and metaphorically. However, it isn’t long before Kirk gets a chance to recapture his youth and the person he has to thank for that is none other than Khan Noonian Singh (Ricardo Montalban).

Kirk ruminates on age as he accepts a pair of antique spectacles from Dr. McCoy (DeForest Kelly) in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982). | Paramount, 1982.

One of the major criticisms of Star Trek: The Motion Picture was its lack of a villain. With this common disapproval in mind, Wrath of Khan’s new producer, Harve Bennett, scoured the original TV series for a suitable antagonist. When he showed the episode ‘Space Seed’ (S1, Ep22) to a previously-disinterested Nicholas Meyer, something suddenly clicked for the fledgling director. “Bennett then showed me ‘Space Seed’, the television episode that introduced the supervillain Khan,” wrote Meyer in his memoir on directing Star Trek movies, The View from the Bridge (2010). “And I did respond to that. Ricardo Montalban was a great actor and, like most great actors, was wasted in roles beneath his talents. So when Bennett suggested using Khan as a character in the new film, I began to become interested.”

Star Trek | The Madness of Benjamin Sisko: Psychosis and Prophecy

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine plunges the grieving Benjamin Sisko into a world of prophets and visions, drawing frequent parallels with mental illness.

Khan and Kirk in Contrast

Khan’s story is rooted in age: born in the 20th century, the augmented tyrant’s self-imposed exile following the Eugenics Wars on Earth left him and 84 of his followers wandering frozen in space. Like Kirk, Khan yearns for an earlier time: “On Earth, 200 years ago… I was a prince, with power over millions,” he reminisces shortly before commencing his plan of revenge on Kirk.

Therein lies the connection between Khan and Kirk: both are bitter over their current situation and the one person – Kirk – that’s forced them both there. 

Khan Noonien Singh (Ricardo Montalbán) reveals himself to the crew of USS Reliant in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982). | Paramount, 1982.

Where the characters diverge is how they approach the bitterness often incumbent on age. Kirk, invigorated by a new mission in charge of Enterprise, meets old flame Carol Marcus (Bibi Besch) and their now-adult son, David (Merritt Butrick), forcing him to re-evaluate his life on a more personal level. Conversely, Khan, consumed by anger and rage, wants nothing but revenge, despite how hollow and pointless that would inevitably be. In another twin facet, both men have advisors wisely counseling them on what to do next.

But whereas Kirk constantly heeds Spock’s (Leonard Nimoy) advice both direct (“Of course, the ship is yours.”) and subtle (“His pattern indicates two-dimensional thinking.”), Khan notably ignores the guidance of his aide, Joachim (Judson Scott). “We’re all with you sir, but consider this,” pleads Joachim shortly after the capture of USS Reliant. “We are free. We have a ship and the means to go where we will. You have proved your superior intellect and defeated the plans of Admiral Kirk. You do not need to defeat him again.”

Khan Noonien Singh (Ricardo Montalbán) and Joachim (Judson Scott) in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan (1982). Montalbán’s one regret was not sharing enough screen time with William Shatner as all of their confrontations were recorded separately, with someone from the script department reading Shatner’s lines. | Paramount, 1982.

Arrogant and fanatical, Khan ignores this sensible advice, and like Spock, Joachim is fated to perish in the Wrath of Khan, crushed underneath the debris of the stricken Reliant. But, unlike the Vulcan, his demise is meaningless, save for helping to incite Khan’s Moby Dick-esque last-gasp stab at destroying Kirk.

Star Trek’s George Takei Takes On Bigotry in His Companion Debut

Join us for To Boldly Ask… George Takei and bring your friends to the free live discussion here on The Companion on October 22nd.

Watching The Wrath of Khan as it enters its 40s, bringing the movie itself into middle age, is a unique experience. Message, Spock? Well, there are many. But the singular conclusion I draw is that age brings experience, but this is often cursed with bitterness. For those that listen to the former but ignore the latter, there will be joy, recaptured youth, and triumph. “You okay, Jim? How do you feel?” asks Dr. McCoy in the film’s closing scene. “Young,” replies an emotional Kirk. “I feel young.”

It’s a fitting final line of dialogue for a movie that, beneath its flashy visual effects of hectic space combat, portrays an element of humanity that, without exception, and even in the futuristic world of Star Trek, affects us all.

As a member of The Companion, you’re supporting original writing and podcasting, for sci-fi fans, by sci-fi fans, and totally free of advertising and clickbait.

The cost of your membership has allowed us to mentor new writers and allowed us to reflect the diversity of voices within fandom. None of this is possible without you. Thank you. 🙂


Testimonial Author Image

Graeme has been writing about old videogames for over ten years for publications such as Retro Gamer and Fusion Books and online with Eurogamer and Antstream Arcade. He’s also a sci-fi nut and is still gutted that Tasha Yar got killed by an oil slick in TNG‘s first season.

You can follow him on Twitter @Wizwords

Looks like you’re using an ad blocker that may prevent our website from working properly. To receive the best experience, please make sure any blockers are switched off and refresh the page.