In the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘Rite of Passage’, Janet Fraiser and Samantha Carter confront a coming-of-age story rooted in fairytale archetypes.
“In the middle of the journey of our life, I found myself in a dark wood where the straight wayDante Alighieri, Divine Comedy (1320)
Going into its fifth and final season on Showtime, Stargate SG-1 was firing on all cylinders. The clever mind games of the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘The Fifth Man’ (S5, Ep4) and the cinematic ‘Red Sky’ (S5, Ep5) were immediately followed by one of the show’s most atypical and endearing installments, ‘Rite of Passage’ (S5, Ep6). SG-1 is only briefly off-world, most of the episode is spent in the infirmary and the primary focus is on the unconventional family life of Dr. Janet Fraiser (Teryl Rothery) and her “alien” adopted daughter Cassandra (Colleen Rennison). We also obtain invaluable glimpses of the private life of Major Samantha Carter (Amanda Tapping), who gets at least briefly liberated from her laboratory.
‘Rite of Passage’ sprang from the fertile brain of Stargate SG-1 Season 3 story editor Heather E. Ash, previously responsible for the delightful ‘Foothold’ (S3, Ep14), in which Jack O’Neill (Richard Dean Anderson) confronted an Evil Janet, and Carter saved the men—and women—of the SGC from an alien invasion. “Your mind is a very strange place,” Don S. Davis told Ash during the filming of ‘Foothold’ and we’re all the beneficiaries of it.
Cassandra: Dominic’s waiting.Stargate SG-1, ‘Rite of Passage’ – S5, Ep6.
Janet Fraiser: Fine. Invite him in. I’m sure he’d love a piece of the birthday cake that Sam went to all the trouble to bake…
Samantha Carter: …buy…
Janet Fraiser: …bring.
Daniel Jackson, Janet Fraiser, and Carson Beckett’s deaths still divide Stargate fandom. Teryl Rothery revisits ‘Heroes, Part 2’ to help us understand why.
Adolescence and Fairytales in ‘Rite of Passage’
Opening on a closeup of Janet and Sam’s hands, director Peter DeLuise pulls back to reveal the Fraiser dining room, decorated for Cassandra’s 15th birthday. Like the growing-pains teen that she is, Cassandra is having none of it. She’d rather go out with her boyfriend Dominic (Richard de Klerk). He dazzles her with a prismatic crystal—a brilliant bit of misdirection, as crystals rarely portend well on Stargate and what we assume to be a plot anvil will prove to be a McGuffin instead. They kiss. Whereupon all hell breaks loose, with porch lights shorting out in a shower of sparks. Seizing Dominic by the arm, Sam is aghast: “What happened? You KISSED her?” A parent’s worst nightmare!
In the final scene, Carter will make light of the domestic drama, teasing Cassandra “that last kiss was impressive. Lights exploded overhead.” But at the moment the only thing to be done is to rush Cassandra to the Cheyenne Mountain infirmary. To collapse a great deal of plot into a few sentences, SG-1 pays a return visit to Cassandra’s home planet, PX-987—first seen in the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘Singularity’ (S1, Ep14)—where Daniel Jackson (Michael Shanks) discovers a secret lab belonging to the Goa’uld Nirrti (Jacqueline Samuda) and evidence of genetic experimentation on young women.
Meanwhile, back at the base, Cassandra is gradually succumbing to a mysterious illness and manifesting inexplicable telekinetic powers. When Nirrti is captured within the SGC by Jack, the stage is set for a life-or-death confrontation between the System Lord and Dr. Fraiser, with Cassandra’s survival hanging in the balance.
To deal with the obvious allegory right up front, the “rite of passage” Cassandra will endure is a metaphorical stand-in for coming of age. Unsurprisingly for a genre show, ‘Rite of Passage’ uses the medium of science fiction to depict the—to put it delicately—hormonal and physiological changes experienced by teenagers, albeit metaphorically. Like any misunderstood teen, Cassandra is apt to explode into such hyperbole as “You’re not my mother… You don’t know anything. You’re just keeping me here because you’re afraid.” And later, “You’re killing me!” – although it’s not an exaggeration in this context.
“I see you. And until your head starts spinning around and even then I will still see you.”Samantha Carter, Stargate SG-1, ‘Rite of Passage’ – S5, Ep6.
Cassandra doesn’t exactly hint at what’s really going on. “I know what’s happening,” she says grimly. “I’m changing … and there’s nothing you can do to stop it … It’s different now. I’m different now. I can do things … I want this to happen, Janet. I can feel a power inside of me. It’s only the beginning.” I am a pubescent teenager, hear me roar, to paraphrase Helen Reddy.
Cassandra tells Dr. Fraiser that she must “go into the forest.” Now we all know from our childhood fairy tales that nothing good happens when you go “into the forest.” It’s where Little Red Riding Hood met the big, bad wolf, and Hansel and Gretel were captured by the cannibalistic witch. As Bruno Bettelheim puts it in The Uses of Enchantment (1976): “Fairy tales were derived from, or give symbolic expression to, initiation rites or other rites de passage—such as metaphoric death of an old, inadequate self in order to reborn on a higher plane of existence.”
Granted, Cassandra is facing physical death, not metaphorical. And being a candidate for Goa’uld implantation is hardly being reborn on a “higher plane,” albeit rebirth of an unwelcome sort, but you get the drift. Furthermore, the Jungian analysis holds that “the sylvan terrors that figure so prominently in children’s tales symbolize the perilous aspects of the unconscious: its tendency to devour or obscure reason.” And what is not Cassandra’s delirium, quoted above, but a case of the reason being obscured and devoured?
Bettelheim again: “Since ancient times the near-impenetrable forest in which we get lost has symbolized the dark, hidden, near-impenetrable world of our unconscious. If we have lost the framework which gave structure to our past life and must now find our way to become ourselves, and have entered this wilderness with an as yet undeveloped personality when we succeed in finding our way out we shall emerge with much more highly developed humanity.” Which is what Cassandra does. (Credit to Ash’s writing, by the way, and Rennison’s playing of it that Cassie comes across as a regular, everyday teen.)
Journalist Justine Gaunt adds: “In many cultures, the forest is dedicated to god or ancestor worship. A place where offerings are made and initiation rituals to test the psychic realm undertaken.” This is precisely what is happening on PX-987, where the children are being sent into the woods to overcome “mind fever.” Not for the last time, we find that Stargate is about a great deal more than snakeheads and space travel.
In the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘Upgrades’, Daniel, Jack, and Samantha become superheroes proving that absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Motherhood in ‘Rite of Passage’
In ‘Rite of Passage,’ we see Janet as rarely before, taxed beyond endurance by the mortal retrovirus consuming her daughter and rewriting her DNA. The high priestess of the Hippocratic oath, Dr. Fraiser had even defended arch villain Apophis himself (Peter Williams) from undoubtedly brutal interrogation by the Air Force and was notable in her dissent when he was turned over to Sokar (David Palffy) in the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘Serpent’s Song’ (S2, Ep18). But she eventually thinks nothing of subduing a guard and pulling his pistol on Nirrti. (In real life this would surely be a court-martial offense, a question which the episode diplomatically begs.) Rothery makes Fraiser’s worn-to-the-marrow fatigue palpable as she paces up and down the corridors of the SGC, desperate for a solution.
She’s even rejected by her daughter, who starts coldly referring to her as “Janet” and “Dr. Fraiser,” despite Sam’s protests. Cassandra is—without knowing it—being torn between two polar-opposite mother figures, the nurturing Janet and the devouring Nirrti. Dr. Fraiser nearly meets her match in Nirrti, played by the “fiery and feisty” (says DeLuise) Samuda, arguably the coldest of the System Lords—and that’s going some. Once captured, Nirrti is given an enviable reveal. She is blocked from our view by General Hammond, and DeLuise’s camera snakes in and around Hammond’s left arm to disclose the hate-filled, hard planes of Nirrti’s face.
If Janet embodies some of the mythic powers of the fairy godmother, Nirrti is an inspired conflation of evil stepmother and wicked archetypes. Like the wicked stepmother of Snow White or the old witch of Rapunzel, Nirrti is driven to possess Cassandra’s youth and vitality. Nirrti covets Cassandra—or at least her DNA—in order to rear her own future host, a grotesque perversion of motherhood. (We assume Nirrti is a female Goa’uld, although the universe of Stargate is a very gender-fluid place.)
Even when facing a bullet through the brain, Nirrti is loath to back down. She eventually makes a half-hearted attempt to break Cassandra’s fever, using Goa’uld ribbon devices. When she tries to bluff her way out of going through with it, she is met with an implacable glare from Dr. Fraiser. Now unarmed, Janet overpowers Nirrti with the potency of a look. Her benevolent maternity is more powerful than Nirrti’s dark magic.
Even before this happy resolution, Cassandra had chosen her adoptive mother over her would-be one. Sensing Nirrti’s as-yet-unseen presence in the operating theater, she calls out for help and reverts to addressing Janet as “mom.” Indeed, Nirrti’s very presence is toxic to Cassandra, who immediately lapses into violent convulsions and an uncontrollable fever, precipitating the climactic showdown.
See Stargate SG-1 stars Richard Dean Anderson as Jack O’Neill, Amanda Tapping as Samantha Carter, and Michael Shanks as Daniel Jackson in Stargate A.I. Version 2.0
Silent Men in ‘Rite of Passage’
While Janet, Sam, and Nirrti dominate the action, the men of SG-1 can do little more than watch helplessly. Here the fairytale continues to resonate – a uniquely feminine space where princes and fathers, if not villainous, are either gently useless or entirely absent. This is epitomized by a touching vignette in the SGC hallway, where Daniel tells Janet, “We all know how tough this has been for you, so if you need anything…” Leaving the thought unfinished, he extends his hand, which Janet clasps and holds close to her. This is one of the Daniel/Janet shipper moments that Shanks and Rothery, in response to fan demand, insinuated into the series. Shippers of Jack/Sam and Daniel/Vala will disagree but Stargate SG-1 handled romance best when it did so through sly nuance and subtext. As Janet leaves, Daniel reaches a forlorn arm towards her, offering comfort she is too preoccupied to receive.
Jack is even more isolated, able to intervene only when straightforward action is required, as in his takedown of Nirrti. During the crucial operating-theater scene, Jack watches from the shadows (cinematography Peter Woeste puts Nirrti half in shadow, half in light, and bathes Janet in a warm glow), while Hammond, Daniel, and Teal’c (Chris Judge) must remain in the observation room, cut off physically and allegorically. Of the four, only Hammond can assert himself over the threat posed by Nirrti, when he backs Janet’s gunpoint play, saying, “I should remind you that the woman holding the gun on you is Cassandra’s mother.”
O’Neill is even exiled from the infirmary when a crucial chess-playing scene was rewritten to include Carter in his stead. Not only does “the blonde” (as fan-fiction writers habitually refer to her) make a logical ‘father’ figure, having chosen to give her own life rather than abandon Cassandra in the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘Singularity,’ but it also gives Sam a chance to showcase her lighter side. It’s only for a moment, though, as Cassie’s ability to levitate a knight leaves Carter with a problem she is hard-pressed to technobabble past.
Since ‘Rite of Passage’ pivots on the Sam-and-Janet axis and leaves little room for masculine assertion, Teal’c is even more of an outsider than Jack, at least until a crucial ‘boardroom’ scene, in which he proposes a coldly pragmatic solution to Nirrti’s demands, pushing Cassandra under the bus. “The life of a child may be sacrificed,” he rationalizes, “but Nirrti possesses valuable information that would be lost of if we allowed her to leave… [Cassandra’s] sacrifice would benefit both our peoples,” Tau’ri and Jaffa.
Sam and Jack are quick to quash this line of argument. “If we put what we may learn or what might happen over her life….” Carter begins, with Jack getting to the bottom line: “It’s time to pack it in.”
O’Neill at least gets to give Nirrti a characteristically terse sendoff:
Nirrti: Without a sample of [Cassandra’s] blood I will have to begin my experiment again.Stargate SG-1, ‘Rite of Passage’ – S5, Ep6.
Jack O’Neill: Aw nuts.
Nirrti: At least you have honored this much of our bargain. In your place, I doubt I would have done the same.
Jack O’Neill: I’ll keep that thought alive.
But what haunts us is, as he escorts the Goa’uld to the Gateroom, is his backward glance at the infirmary. Framed by the doorway, we see Carter and Fraiser hugging Cassandra. Is it a glimpse of the family life Jack has lost? A sad realization that he is outside this particular domestic tableau, looking in forlornly? Probably both.
In the Stargate SG-1 episode ‘There but for the Grace of God’, we join our heroes on the other side of the quantum mirror for life’s what-ifs.
Queer Subtext in ‘Rite of Passage’
No discussion of ‘Rite of Passage’ is complete without addressing the elephant in the room or “Cassandra Has Two Mommies” as fans have nicknamed the episode. As one novice Stargate SG-1 viewer exclaimed of the Sapphic subtext, “Could they have been more obvious? That opening scene was way too cozy!” Although Stargate SG-1 canon holds that Sam and Janet are BFFs, ‘Rite of Passage’ was not the first time that the series’ writers and directors had hinted at Something More.
LGBTQ shipper anvils were also dropped in the Stargate SG-1 episodes ‘A Hundred Days’ (S3, Ep17), ‘2010’ (S4, Ep16), ‘Meridian’ (S5, Ep21), and ‘Entity’ (S4, Ep20), which ends with Sam and Janet holding hands.
As scholars Liz Millward, Janice G. Dodd, and Irene Fubara-Manuel write in the book Killing the Lesbians: A Symbolic Annihilation on Film and Television (p. 169), “In addition to working closely with each other to solve innumerable scientific problems, Sam and Janet jointly bring up an alien daughter named Cassie, wear matching pink and blue cardigans, provide emotional support to each other, and are constantly in the frame together.” Or, as fan-fiction author Tara Phoenix cuts to the chase in re Janet, “Her chemistry with Sam is simply off the charts.” (Emphasis in the original.)
Millward & Co. resume: “As if the showrunners suddenly realized how this material could be decoded, Sam is given a serious boyfriend (another Pete), who proposes to her and Janet inexplicably shows romantic interest in a male documentary filmmaker just before she is killed off, although Sam is still the chief mourner at her funeral.” Yes, well, that was still a few seasons down the road.
‘Rite of Passage’ leaves us instead with the happy domestic scene of Sam and Cassandra playing chess… and Janet’s beatific smile, an iconic closeup that adorns every tribute video. It’s how we wish to remember her.
Update June 20th, 2022:
As a member of The Companion, you’re supporting original writing and podcasting, for sci-fi fans, by sci-fi fans, and totally free of advertising and clickbait.
The cost of your membership has allowed us to mentor new writers and allowed us to reflect the diversity of voices within fandom. None of this is possible without you. Thank you. 🙂
David McKee works as a business reporter and editor by day in order to feed his science-fiction habit on nights and weekends. He caught the bug way back when Space: 1999 was airing. He lives in Augusta, Georgia, with his wife and their cat.