Skip to main content

Fandom

How Red Dwarf Fandom Broke All The Rules: Part 1 | Red Dwarf

There are few shows that can follow you through a lifetime, but for me, Red Dwarf is one of them. My memories of the ragtag stranded-in-deep-space crew and their comedic misadventures begin when I was a small child, watching my dad do impressions of The Cat, and take me right through university binges and 20-something fancy dress parties, all the way into my 30s. Lister, the slobby last human alive (Craig Charles), his uptight hologram roommate Rimmer (Chris Barrie), evolved Cat (Danny John-Jules), fussy robot Kryton (Robert Llewellyn) and senile computer Holly (Norman Lovett and Hattie Heyridge) have all been in my life for as long as my own brother has.

It’s unlikely that a TV show will run for 32 years, and even more unlikely that it will be popular enough to return time and again after lengthy hiatuses, the longest of which was 10 years. And yet somehow Red Dwarf did all of this without the weight of social media behind it. So how does a show build up a powerful fanbase in the years before Twitter (and before what most people would recognise as ‘the internet’), and how did that fanbase resurrect a long-dormant show? “There’s no way we would have been brought back without the fans,” Red Dwarf co-creator Doug Naylor tells me when we catch up over the phone.

“No-one would have gone ‘you know what would be a good idea? You know that show that’s not been on TV for the best part of 10 years? Why don’t we bring that back, because the cast are still all alive?’ No-one would have done that… It was because the fans wanted more.”

Doug Naylor
Red Dwarf co-creator Doug Naylor with some of Kryten’s extended family. British viewers can binge Red Dwarf on UKTV Play. | UKTV

“So what is it?” – The Cat

There are few shows that can follow you through a lifetime, but for me, Red Dwarf is one of them. My memories of the ragtag stranded-in-deep-space crew and their comedic misadventures begin when I was a small child, watching my dad do impressions of The Cat, and take me right through university binges and 20-something fancy dress parties, all the way into my 30s. Lister, the slobby last human alive (Craig Charles), his uptight hologram roommate Rimmer (Chris Barrie), evolved Cat (Danny John-Jules), fussy robot Kryton (Robert Llewellyn) and senile computer Holly (Norman Lovett and Hattie Heyridge) have all been in my life for as long as my own brother has.

It’s unlikely that a TV show will run for 32 years, and even more unlikely that it will be popular enough to return time and again after lengthy hiatuses, the longest of which was 10 years. And yet somehow Red Dwarf did all of this without the weight of social media behind it. So how does a show build up a powerful fanbase in the years before Twitter (and before what most people would recognise as ‘the internet’), and how did that fanbase resurrect a long-dormant show? “There’s no way we would have been brought back without the fans,” Red Dwarf co-creator Doug Naylor tells me when we catch up over the phone.

“No-one would have gone ‘you know what would be a good idea? You know that show that’s not been on TV for the best part of 10 years? Why don’t we bring that back, because the cast are still all alive?’ No-one would have done that… It was because the fans wanted more.”

Doug Naylor
Red Dwarf co-creator Doug Naylor with some of Kryten’s extended family. British viewers can binge Red Dwarf on UKTV Play. | UKTV

“So what is it?” – The Cat

But before we get to the show’s various resurrections, let’s first go back to where it all began, when Naylor and his writing partner Rob Grant were writing a sci-fi comedy, blissfully ignorant to how much of a notoriously hard sell the genre is. “We thought we’d try something, and if we thought it was funny and our mates thought it was funny then that was all we needed to do,” Naylor chuckles. TV studios disagreed. Despite the popularity of science-fiction in cinemas in the mid-1980s, a sci-fi sitcom was a step too far for TV commissioners, and it took four failed BBC pitches and three years for the show to get picked up by BBC Manchester, for broadcast in 1988. 

But the BBC were still nervous of the sci-fi element, despite Naylor and Grant “lying like mad” and claiming that there was going to be very little sci-fi in their show. For the first few episodes they filmed for series one, Naylor and Grant “kept the science-fiction content to practically zero, it was just a sitcom on a spaceship, really, with some weird characters,” Naylor says. “And then we did ‘Future Echoes’.” The episode (S1, Ep2, although it was the fourth to be shot) weaves together timelines, with glimpses of the near-future plaguing the ship’s crew. It’s a mind-boggling episode, tricky to explain or rehearse, but the live audience’s reaction to it was encouraging. After that, Naylor and Grant leaned much harder into the show’s sci-fi elements.

They were commissioned for a second series and drew healthy viewing figures of 4.75 million, but still had little idea of what viewers actually thought of the show (although they knew that critics weren’t overly keen). But the fans were already getting behind Red Dwarf. The Official Red Dwarf Fan Club was founded in 1990 (to Naylor’s surprise and slight mystification), and they quickly had a rudimentary website and magazine up and running. According to the current chairman of the fan club, James Bull, the fan club’s first magazine was “very basic, it was just photocopied,” and advertising for the fan club was mostly via word-of-mouth. Bull came across them in the ‘90s and recalls writing letters to the magazine, as that was the only way of communicating with other fans at the time.

“We are talking Jape Of The Decade.” – Holly

That said, there was one direct link to the fans that Red Dwarf could enjoy – the live studio audience. Naylor says the audience acted as a great barometer for the quality of the episodes, in that “if they don’t think it’s funny they won’t laugh”. By series two onwards, the live audiences knew what to expect from the show, and became much more responsive. Bull, who has been in the Red Dwarf live audience a few times, says that “It’s like theatre, but you’re more involved than theatre I think. It’s like pantomime, in a way,” in that the actors feed off of and encourage audience reaction. “I think it gives them their best performance because we are there,” Bull adds. “You do get that excitement as well, that you’re physically adding to what’s going to be [on screen].” There aren’t many sci-fi fandoms that get to actually be in the room when their favourite show is being made, but Red Dwarf is, to this day, one of them.

Aside from the direct audience feedback on filming days, Naylor and the team were pretty clueless as to what the fans thought of the show, something he’s relieved about, in retrospect. “I remember someone saying ‘how did you cope knowing that hardcore science-fiction fans absolutely hated the first few series’?’ And we didn’t know. We had no idea,” he laughs heartily. “We didn’t know, so we didn’t make any changes at all, and I’m not sure we would have anyway. You want to make the show you want to make, in the way you want to make it. Obviously, you want to make it better all the time and make it funnier and all the rest, and get a bigger budget. In fact, we were quite cavalier, especially me, about changing the format completely.” That format change refers to Series 3 when Llewellyn’s Kryten was added to the regular cast, and Starbug was introduced, becoming a key new set for the show. These changes weren’t in response to fan feedback though, they were simply trying to make the show better. Naylor tells me that the early series’ “had a decent budget, would you believe? It was just shockingly produced… The sets were just bits of wood with a couple of coats of grey paint, and that would have got absolutely battered if it had gone out like that [in the age of social media]… it could have been killed pretty early with fan criticism, I guess.”

An extremely fresh faced Craig Charles as Lister and Chris Barrie as Rimmer, the slacker and the martinet whose dynamic defined Red Dwarf. | UKTV.

Bull agrees that the Red Dwarf fandom could have turned out very different if the show had started life in the social media era. “I think social media has ruined a lot of fanbases, definitely,” he says. “The trouble nowadays is anonymity, people think they can say anything and get away with it, ‘I have this right to speak my mind and it doesn’t matter if it affects anybody because nobody can see me, I can’t be touched’. And as we’ve learned from recent things, that’s not the case.” Because Red Dwarf fans had to communicate either in person, via letters, or via very slow emails back in the early ‘90s, they were simply nicer to each other.

“You can’t confuse Rimmer with a book. A book’s got a spine.” – Lister

Quite early on in Red Dwarf’s life, Naylor and Grant had already started expanding the world of the show, in the way that many fan-favourite shows do these days – via tie-in novels and extra behind-the-scenes content. At the time, in the pre-DVD era, that sort of extra content was a rarity, but Naylor admits that there was no cynical plan in place to draw in viewers or appease fans with this content, it was simply something him and Grant wanted to do. “If you’d talked to me then about extra content, and how it would expand the franchise, I would have just gone ‘what?’ I wouldn’t have understood,” he says. 

Initially, the BBC wanted them to produce a ‘making of’ book, but Grant and Naylor wanted to write novels instead. Penguin published the first Red Dwarf novel (Infinity Welcomes Careful Drivers) in 1989. It would be followed by three further novels. Naylor wanted “to be able to do all the things we can’t afford to do on the TV series and make it this vast ship that we’ve always wanted, and be able to go anywhere and do anything, and we can take some of the tropes that we’ve used on TV and expand them in the novel.” Tie-in novels are a common part of sci-fi shows with a large fanbase these days, but it’s extremely unusual, even now, that those novels would be written by the showrunners themselves. Both Steven Moffat and Russell T Davies have written novelisations of their Doctor Who episodes, and they have contributed stories to Doctor Who: Adventures in Lockdown, alongside other Who writers, but those were done years after their showrunner tenures had ended. For TV creators to be expanding on the universe of their show in novel form, while that show was still airing, is very unusual, and an example of Red Dwarf remaining creator-led.

Then came the Smeg Ups and Smeg Outs, two videos containing outtakes from the show. These videos came about, again, not because of some pre-planned fan engagement strategy, but because Naylor was insulted that outtakes compilation show It’ll Be Alright On The Night hadn’t wanted to use any of Red Dwarf’s excellent bloopers, so they decided to release them themselves. These days, bloopers are a beloved addition to the shows we enjoy, whether we’re watching them as DVD extras or via official social media accounts. But Red Dwarf has an advantage over its non-comedic sci-fi siblings: It has a cast of comedians. “They’re quite clever, the cast, especially Chris [Barrie],” Bull says, of his experience of watching the show live. “He tends to add in [a blooper] if he feels that the audience are a tiny bit low.” There’s nothing like causing your castmates to corpse to get an audience laughing, especially if you’re a skilled impressionist and improviser, as Barrie is. The Red Dwarf outtakes remain, to this day, the gold standard of sci-fi outtakes, partly because the show is a comedy to begin with, partly because of the skill of the actors, and partly because they were playing up to a live audience. It’s no wonder that Naylor and Grant saw the potential in releasing them on VHS.

While Naylor is adamant that there was no specific strategy in mind regarding the release of extra content, Bull has other thoughts. “[The extra material] was always released in between the series’, and I think they were very clever at keeping people’s attention… You don’t feel as though it’s been two years since the last series.” Smeg Ups, for instance, was released on VHS in 1994, with Smeg Outs following in 1995, placing them in the four-year gap between series’ 6 and 7. But the people behind the show weren’t the only ones keeping Red Dwarf going when it was off air – the fans were doing their share too.

Shoutouts: A huge thanks to Sirena Wong, Matthew Knapton, and Laura Kitching, three of our Kickstarter backers who made The Companion possible! Extra special thanks to Ben at UKTV for hooking us up with Doug. British viewers can binge Red Dwarf on UKTV Play.

Read Part 2

Testimonial Author Image

Abigail is a journalist and writer currently living in Oxford. She can still quote late-90s films and TV shows at length but has forgotten everything she once knew about maths.

Follow her on Twitter @Abby_Chandler

Recommended Articles